Taubman Library Talks

Webinar link: https://umich.zoom.us/j/95035600624

Date & Time: Monday June 10, 2024, 1-2:00pm EST (Detroit/Michigan/Eastern) Time

Add to your calendar | Time Zone Convertor

Registration: No registration required

Accessibility: Live CART captioning; transcript available with recording. Please contact Whitney Townsend (whitneyt@umich.edu) to discuss additional accommodations by Monday, May 27, 2024.

Recorded: Yes, a full transcript and recording is available below.

Files: .pptx slide download | .pdf slide download | via Google Drive [slides will be available on the day of the webinar]

Presenters: Mark MacEachern & Whitney Townsend (Informationists, University of Michigan)

Description:

Behind the Scenes of "A Critical Analysis of Peer Reviewer Comments on Systematic Review Search Strategies"

Numerous studies have demonstrated the poor quality of published systematic reviews, which often includes poorly conducted and reported search strategies. While many groups (such as PRISMA) provide recommendations on how to report search strategies, it's unclear how rigorously the search strategies are reviewed during the peer review process. At minimum, we would expect egregious search strategy issues to be addressed through peer review, but we hypothesized that this is seldom the case. We were able to explore this hypothesis through open peer review (OPR). We analyzed the search strategies of published systematic reviews, and then looked for search-related comments in the associated OPR documentation.

In this webinar, Taubman Library Talks co-hosts Mark MacEachern and Whitney Townsend will pull back the curtain on a pre-Covid research project that didn't quite make it to the publishing finish line. In addition to discussing the methods and results of the project, Mark and Whitney will give an open and honest assessment of the project's challenges, what they learned from them, and what they might do differently in the future.

Relevant Links

• Project Data Deposit (Deep Blue Data): https://doi.org/10.7302/acjm-cz18
• Draft manuscript "Analyzing Peer Review Practices of Systematic Review Search Methodology through Open Peer Review " (Deep Blue Documents) https://dx.doi.org/10.7302/23162
• Peer Review Rubric for Published Searches (pdf via Google Drive)
• Peer Review Rubric for Published Searches (pdf download)

This recording is 55 minutes long and includes a closed caption option and a rolling, searchable, downloadable transcript.

• For easier viewing of small images, use the double diagonal arrow icon to expand the viewer.
• If you are unable to view the video due to website or software restrictions at your institution, please contact Whitney Townsend (whitneyt@umich.edu)